27 September 2001, 10:53 Buba's Welteke says Tobin tax unworkable; would raise cost of intl trading
LONDON (AFX) - Bundesbank president Ernst Welteke rejected calls to
introduce a global tax on speculative capital flows - the Tobin tax -
as unworkable and certain to increase the cost of international
trading.
In a comment piece for the Financial Times, Welteke said the Tobin
tax, first proposed 30 years ago, is "again being extolled as (a) kind
of cure-all" for problems linked to the apparent unfairness of the
financial markets.
"It is supposed to be about stemming speculative capital flows,
these purportedly being the cause of financial and monetary crises."
But "not all short-term transactions are harmful," he commented.
"Currency trading, which tries to exploit price differentials, has
an important role to play in terms of the functional viability of the
markets. This arbitrage ensures uniform prices. A tax on currency
trades would jeopardise its role and undermine market stability."
A Tobin tax would also do nothing to suppress "the hallmarks of
crises", namely "severe losses of confidence, highly volatile share
prices and nosedives on the equity markets."
Worse still, because "it is not possible to distinguish between the
supposed evil of speculation and the benefits of external trade ... a
tax on currency trading would affect all its forms and make
international trading more expensive.
"That would be a disadvantage in terms of the worldwide division of
labour. The less developed countries would be the ones to suffer," he
said.
In terms of its implementation, "difficulties are likely to be
encountered not only with regard to countries' political will, but also
in terms of determining the instrument's ideal technical form."
He added: "If we want to avoid crises, we must tackle them at their
source: poor economic and financial policy, banking difficulties or
unsound developments in the real economy. Speculative capital flows are
merely the symptoms of suspected imbalances."
© 1999-2024 Forex EuroClub
All rights reserved