23 May 2001, 12:27 OUTLOOK: ECB to leave rates unchanged today; further cuts seen in Q3
---- by STEVE WHITEHOUSE ----
PARIS (AFX) - The European Central Bank will leave interest rates
unchanged at today's governing council meeting, but further cuts in
rates are expected in the third quarter, economists said.
The ECB surprised markets by cutting leading interest rates at its
last council meeting on May 10 after many council members had insisted
in the run-up to the meeting that they were concerned about
inflationary pressures.
ECB president Wim Duisenberg said the decision was the result of
"somewhat lower inflationary pressure over the medium term" and this
means that the way is open for further monetary easing in the months
ahead, economists said.
It is too early to cut interest rates again this week, but another
easing move is likely in the third quarter, or possibly even in June,
they said.
In a poll of 27 economists last week by AFX News and Agence
France-Presse, all said they expect the minimum bid rate on the ECB's
main refinancing operations to be left unchanged at 4.50 pct at today's
meeting.
The majority of those polled -- 17 of the 27 -- forecast that the
next easing move will come in the third quarter. Five predicted that
rates will be cut in June, while three said the ECB will ease in either
June or July. One forecast a fourth quarter easing move and one said he
expects no move over the next 12 months.
Economists therefore appear to be paying little heed to Bundesbank
president Ernst Welteke's remark that the May 10 cut was "not an
appetizer".
"Now that the ECB has decided to become more reactive, it has to
continue in the same direction," said Marc Touati of Natexis Banques
Populaires, who was alone in forecasting a cut at the May 10 meeting.
"The fact that the ECB considers inflation risks to have evaporated
will mean that rate cut expectations will take shape again as (weak)
economic indicators are released," said Emmanuel Ferry of Exane.
"We are reckoning on a more decisive cut of 50 basis points on June
7, in view of the negative news flow ahead, not only in Germany but
also in Italy and, to a lesser extent, in France," he said.
The timing of the next rate cut may be partly affected by inflation
figures, although the fact that euro zone inflation was well above the
ECB's 2.0 pct price stability ceiling did not deter the central bank
from easing rates at its last meeting.
At that time inflation stood at 2.6 pct, but April figures released
last week showed it accelerating to 2.9 pct, and economists said it is
likely to rise again in May.
Inflation is likely to ease again with the June data released in
July and this could give the ECB justification for a further rate cut,
economists said.
"The ECB is doubtless waiting to have a more favourable inflation
figure before cutting rates again," said Frederic Pretet of Credit
Agricole Indosuez, who expects an easing move in late July or early
August.
However, the May 10 cut has shown that the ECB is paying only
limited attention to current headline inflation figures. Duisenberg
insisted that the ECB is focussing on risks to price stability in the
medium-term future, which he defined as 18-24 months ahead.
ECB vice-president Christian Noyer said markets had been mistaken
in assuming that the central bank was targeting short-term inflation,
whereas it is actually targeting inflation in the medium term.
And medium-term inflation expectations are more benign than the
current headline rate, economists noted.
"Given that Euroland industry price prospects in the European
Commission survey are presently at their lowest level since December
1999, the ECB should ease monetary policy again," said Touati.
The ECB also regards M3 money supply growth as very important to
future inflation risks, and it pinned the May 10 rate cut largely on
new information on distortions in the M3 data.
Duisenberg said the distortions, relating to the inclusion of
non-resident holdings of marketable paper in the M3 data, meant that
the risk to price stability from monetary growth had been overstated in
the past.
And once the distortions are removed, M3 growth is now thought to
be undershooting, rather than overshooting, the ECB's 4.5 pct reference
value, economists said.
Duisenberg said M3 growth would have averaged 4.3 pct in the first
quarter, rather than the published figure of 4.8 pct, if non-resident
holdings of units and shares in money market funds had not been
included.
And in its May monthly bulletin last week, the ECB said a second
distortion that it is studying could be of similar magnitude to the
first, which would mean that M3 growth is running at around 3.8 pct
after adjusting for both distortions.
Such a rate of M3 growth could well be used to justify another rate
cut, economists said.
Signs of weaker economic growth could also be used as an argument
for additional monetary easing, they said.
Although the ECB is mandated to put price stability before
considerations of economic growth, Duisenberg cited downward revisions
in euro zone growth forecasts as the second reason for the May 10 rate
cut, so the ECB clearly has one eye on European growth, they said.
"Given the apparent shift in the focus of the ECB towards
short-term risks to growth, it is not unlikely that there will be more
rate cuts. This is especially the case as euro area indicators should
continue to be weak over the summer," said Michael Schubert of
Commerzbank.
"Further economic slowdown and a slowing in the headline inflation
rate will become apparent by end of June. It will take until then too
for the dust to have settled from last week's surprising decision. By
the beginning of the third quarter, the ECB could therefore cut rates
again," said Julian von Landesberger of HypoVereinsbank.
Economists said they will certainly be paying more attention to
economic data than to remarks from ECB officials, having been
wrongfooted by their comments in the run-up to the May 10 meeting.
Comments and speeches are now regarded as having limited value in
forecasting future interest rate decisions, despite Duisenberg's
previous commitment to prepare markets for rate moves where possible.
The ECB's credibility has been seriously damaged by the
contradiction between words and actions, economists said.
"In spite of Mr Duisenberg's justifications, the May 10 rate cut
was another blow to the credibility of the ECB. After convincing the
markets of the need to maintain a tough stance against inflationary
risks, the U-turn of the monetary authorities increased confusion,"
said Rodolfo Dozio of Comit.
The ECB has a chance to regain some credibility by easing monetary
policy further, however, Touati said.
"In this way it can climb a few rungs on the credibility
ladder...whereas on the other hand the Fed risks going down a few rungs
as a result of a policy which is a bit too brutal. This could finally
bring about a lasting improvement in the fortunes of the euro," he
said.
© 1999-2024 Forex EuroClub
All rights reserved